The Badminton World Federation (BWF) has recently announced its intention to trial a new scoring system—the 3x15 format—in an effort to make matches more dynamic and engaging. This change, endorsed by the BWF Council, aims to replace the existing 3x21 scoring method. The new system will be tested across selected Continental Championships, Grade 3 tournaments, and various national and international leagues starting from April 2025.

What Makes the 3x15 System Stand Out? 

The proposed 3x15 system introduces a shorter game format with each match being a best-of-three games, and each game played up to 15 points. In case of a tie at 14-all, the game continues until a player reaches 20 points. The BWF hopes that this modification will not only make games quicker but also encourage a more attacking style of play, making the sport more appealing to a broader audience.

Mixed Reactions from Players: Will It Really Benefit the Sport?

 While some players see potential benefits in the new system, others are skeptical. Indian shuttler HS Prannoy, known for his marathon matches, expressed mixed feelings about the change. Although the shorter matches might benefit older players like him by aiding recovery, he remains unsure if this will enhance the sport’s appeal. "A 21-point match typically lasts around 70 minutes, which isn't excessively long. If we want better viewership, we should consider improving other aspects like scheduling and broadcasting rather than changing the scoring system," Prannoy stated during a training camp ahead of the Badminton Asia Team Championships.

Initial Feedback: Players Prefer the Status Quo for Major Tournaments 

Feedback collected by BAI Secretary General Sanjay Mishra indicates that while players are open to experimenting with the new system in leagues, they prefer retaining the existing 3x21 format for major tournaments. "Players feel that a 15-point game doesn’t provide enough time to showcase their skills," Mishra explained. He also noted that countries like China, Malaysia, and Indonesia might oppose the change, as it diminishes their advantage in fitness and endurance.

Potential Benefits for Older Players and Match Scheduling 

For older players like Prannoy, the 3x15 system could be a game-changer by reducing physical strain and aiding recovery between matches. However, Prannoy emphasized that more critical issues need addressing, such as extending the duration of major tournaments like the All England Open. "BWF should treat these events like Grand Slams in tennis, giving players more rest days and time for media engagements," he added.

Concerns Over Match Quality and Strategic Play 

Not all experts are convinced that the 3x15 system will benefit the sport. Shlok Ramchandran, former India doubles player and now Coaching Director at Synergy Badminton Academy in California, believes the shorter format could compromise match quality. "Stamina will still matter, but strategies will shift towards aggressive, direct play. This might lead to more upsets but could reduce the depth and creativity, especially in doubles," he noted. Ramchandran suggested an alternative format—two games of 21 points with a third game of 11—to balance excitement and strategic depth.

Lessons from the Past: BWF’s History of Scoring System Experiments 

The BWF has a history of experimenting with scoring systems, including the short-lived best-of-five, 7-points-per-game format in 2002. Olympian and former national champion Aparna Popat, who played during this period, expressed caution about constantly changing rules. "If there’s concrete evidence that shorter matches boost commercial appeal, it’s worth trying. But we must ensure that it doesn’t compromise the quality of the sport," she warned.

Looking Ahead: Will the 3x15 System Become the New Norm?

 The trial period for the 3x15 scoring system will run from April to October 2025, after which the BWF will evaluate its impact on the sport. While the shorter format might attract new audiences and make scheduling easier, it remains to be seen whether it will gain widespread acceptance among players and fans alike.

BWF’s Bold Step: Introducing the 3x15 Scoring System for a More Dynamic Game 

In conclusion, while the 3x15 scoring system promises faster, more explosive matches, the badminton community remains divided on its long-term benefits. The upcoming trials will be crucial in determining whether this bold move by the BWF will redefine the future of badminton or be another experiment that falls short of expectations.