Guna, Madhya Pradesh — In a shocking and controversial statement, BJP MLA Pannalal Shakya made a bizarre remark during the inauguration of the "PM College of Excellence" in his Guna constituency, advising students to open motorcycle puncture repair shops instead of relying on college degrees to secure a livelihood. The comment has sparked a wave of criticism and debates on the value of education, especially in light of the event being part of the Union Government's initiative to boost higher education across Madhya Pradesh.

Addressing the students and attendees during the event on Sunday, which was virtually launched by Union Home Minister Amit Shah, Shakya said, “We are inaugurating a PM College of Excellence today, but I want to remind you that degrees alone will not guarantee a future. Instead, consider opening a motorcycle puncture repair shop. At least, you will earn a livelihood.”

The remark has raised eyebrows not just because of its unexpected nature, but also because it was made at an event celebrating higher education. The college, which is part of the "PM College of Excellence" scheme launched by the central government to improve educational standards in 55 districts, aims to provide students with advanced learning opportunities and better career prospects.

Bizarre Advice Sparks Public Backlash

The MLA’s statement quickly went viral on social media, with many students and education advocates criticizing his stance on education. One student, speaking to India Today, remarked, “This statement from the MLA is a clear reflection of the government's disregard for the true value of education. Are degrees now useless?”

Social media users and political opponents were equally vocal, calling the remark not only dismissive of higher education but also out of touch with the aspirations of the youth. Critics argue that such statements diminish the importance of academic achievements, which are crucial for developing skilled professionals in a variety of fields, from medicine and engineering to the arts and sciences.

Pannalal Shakya’s Reflections on Education and Environment

Shakya’s controversial remarks did not stop at education. During his address, he also commented on the state’s environment policies. In a reference to the mega sapling plantation drive in Indore, which set a world record by planting over 1.1 million saplings in 24 hours, Shakya pointed out that while tree planting efforts were commendable, there was little focus on nurturing and preserving the trees. He compared this to the neglect of the ‘panchtatva’ (five elements: earth, air, water, solar energy, and sky) that form the essence of life.

“The world is planting trees, but no one is taking the effort to water and protect them. We need to preserve the panchtatva, the five elements that are part of the human body,” Shakya stated.

He also raised concerns over encroachments on government land along rivers and drains, claiming that while there is significant discourse on pollution and environmental degradation, the necessary actions are often lacking.

The BJP MLA’s Controversial Viewpoint on Government Land Encroachments

In a separate part of his address, Shakya commented on the ongoing issue of government land encroachments, particularly along the rivers and drains in his constituency. He argued that while many are quick to raise alarms about environmental issues like pollution, the real concern lies in preserving and protecting the land and natural resources. “There is too much talk about pollution, but no concrete actions to safeguard the environment and government land,” he added